Is he wrong for telling his wife that the lock on his daughter’s door should not be removed until his brother-in-law and his daughters have left their house?
Move-in Day
The husband’s brother-in-law, Sammy, moved in with his twin daughters, Olivia and Sloane, after losing his home due to a divorce ten months ago. His sister and her husband have a daughter, Zoey, who is 16 years old, and she and her cousins are not very close, but they get along fine.
No Respect for Privacy
Olivia & Sloane have been disrespectful toward Zoey’s privacy since they moved in. They enter her room and take whatever they want, including makeup, phone accessories, clothes, and even Zoey’s school laptop. Zoey has complained about it many times, and the husband has already asked the girls to stop taking Zoey’s belongings and to respect her privacy. However, his wife and Sammy see nothing wrong with this behavior, believing it to be typical teenage girl behavior.
The Last Straw
The last straw was when Zoey saved up for over a month to buy a $60 m.a.c makeup kit that looked like a paint set, and one of the girls, Sloane, took it without permission and ruined it by mixing shades while using it. Zoey was devastated, and the husband told his wife about it. She said she would ask Sloane to apologize, but the husband decided to buy a lock for Zoey’s door after he found her moving valuable belongings out of the house due to this incident.
Sammy and His Daughters’ Reaction
When Sammy and his daughters saw the lock, they were agitated, and Sammy asked about it. The husband told him about the incident, and Sammy responded by saying that his daughters aren’t thieves. He believed it was normal for girls of the same age to borrow each other’s stuff. Sammy also criticized Zoey for buying expensive adult makeup, suggesting that the husband’s wife should take care of this “defect” in Zoey’s personality and accused him of being overprotective and babying Zoey.
The Argument with the Wife
The husband told Sammy that this was between him and his wife. However, his wife shamed him for putting a lock on Zoey’s door and preventing her cousins from “spending time” with her. She argued that he should treat them like his own daughters. The husband refused to remove the lock until Sammy and his daughters moved out of their house.
The Family’s Reaction
The wife got mad and accused the husband of implying that they kicked Sammy and his family out. She claimed that her family would hate him for this. The husband reminded her that he let Sammy and his family move in, which was something her family refused to do. He blamed them for the disturbance caused in their home. Since then, everyone has been giving the husband and Zoey the silent treatment, and the wife is very upset about the situation.
The Outcome
The husband is standing by his decision to lock Zoey’s door and believes that his wife and Sammy are in the wrong. He feels that he needs to protect Zoey’s privacy and property rights. The situation has caused tension in their household, and the family’s reaction has made it difficult for the husband to resolve the issue.
The Internet Weighs In
The husband took his story to the internet to see if he was being unreasonable or if he should stand by his decision. Here is what a few had to say on Reddit.
“Don’t back down. You are the only one sticking up for Zoey. If her cousins want to use expensive makeup, give them your wife’s. I guarantee she won’t appreciate sharing anymore. They need to start behaving like appreciative guests”
“Your wife harbors someone who tells you that Zoey has a “defect” in her personality for buying an expensive make up kit, that’s the kind of thing that has people thinking about divorce.”
More Opinions
“My sister would do this all the time when we were teenagers and my parents always told me to work it out ourselves. I felt helpless to do anything because I couldn’t always be there to stop her and it was infuriating. My dad got me a lock and it really made me feel like he recognized my frustrations and supported me. This dude is doing a great service to his daughter. A teen needs privacy and security, especially when they’ve felt powerless in their own home.”
“Sammy sounds like he is spoiling his daughters and justifying their actions by blaming the victim (Zoey). Kicking them out may be a good idea at this point.”
Source: Reddit
She Hides the Fact That Her Cousin’s Fiancé Was Her “Summer Camp Fling” for Three Years. Her Cousin Is Furious.
Is She Wrong for Not Telling Her Cousin That Her Fiancé Was Her “Summer Camp Fling” for 3 Years?
She Hides the Fact That Her Cousin’s Fiancé Was Her “Summer Camp Fling” for Three Years. Her Cousin Is Furious
Is She Wrong for Not Wanting To Attend Her Brother in Law Daughter’s Memorial Birthday Due to His Competitive Approach to Grief?
A woman finds herself in a strained relationship with her brother-in-law (John), which has deteriorated recently after six years of being part of the same family.
Is She Wrong for Not Wanting To Attend Her Brother in Law Daughter’s Memorial Birthday Due to His Competitive Approach to Grief?
Is She Wrong for Not Wanting to Stop Her Stepdaughter from Calling Her Mom?
Is She Wrong for Not Wanting to Stop Her Stepdaughter from Calling Her Mom?